Can Startups De-FaceBook?

Some call themselves social operating sites or people platforms. Others stick to the widely accepted social media and/or social networking nomenclature. You say tomato, Steve Jobs says apple. Regardless of classification, newbies to social like Pip.io, Diaspora and OneSocialWeb are pitching their sites as untainted alternatives to Mark Zuckerberg’s privacy invading juggernaut, FaceBook. The ire over FaceBook’s controversial Open Graph application and its “Like” tool has spawned QuitFaceBookDay.com, a campaign calling for users to cancel their accounts on May 31st. Be that as it may, if people are so up in arms over FaceBook, why are these new sites struggling to get off the ground? Why have only 13,000 of FaceBook’s 400 million members vowed to sever ties with the social network?

I think the inconvenient truth of the matter is that for all their complaining, users are experiencing a crisis of conscience and a struggle for identity. FaceBook initially marketed itself as a place for friends. Those friends created the rules of the game. Users started marketing themselves, their interests, their industries, their affiliations. It should not be called invasion of privacy if you’re doing the striptease. And stripteases get noticed.

Companies, large and small, caught on to the power of social networking and influencing in marketing their products and services. The place for friends changed into the home for honchos. FaceBook traditionalists, if they could really be called such, may hate the thought of sharing face time with big business but that’s the price of innovation.

I’m sure many FaceBook users are tempted to test the social waters, whether or not they completely opt to jump from Zuckerberg’s ship. But the reality is FaceBook successfully separated itself from the pack by continuously improving its model, not settling on one formula or aspect of social networking to survive. For social newbies to truly compete with FaceBook, they would be wise to forego an independent strategy. They should outsource digital performance marketing expertise to draw from what Zuckerberg has mastered and invest in innovation, improved analytics and optimization to drive results far greater than 13,000.